Announcements for going straight at a crossing

[Marinus van Deudekom]

@Con-Hennekens I do see what You mean but….. There’s a but, if your wish would be fullfiled when would you have the crossings be anounced, all the the crossings wirch woula lead to a constant talking person if you drive in a city. I think you’re better of placing a warning point yoursel while planning the route.

[Con Hennekens]

@Marinus-van-Deudekom, you cannot place warnings yourself because you don't know beforehand when a crossing will not be visible. But I do agree in urban situations this could be undesirable to a certain level. On the other hand, I really would not mind an instruction to go straight. That happens a lot already as it is, in the form of which lane to use. I guess something clever would have to be thought up. Our devs are good at that

[Marinus van Deudekom]

@Con-Hennekens sorry Con. I don’ agree with you this time. While planning a route à crossing next to curve might warn you. Taking a look on streetview gives you the overview you need to decide wether or not you pkace a warning shaping point.

[Con Hennekens]

@Marinus-van-Deudekom, no problem, we do not always have to agree. I think it would prevent possible dangerous situations. And I think it is not really problematic to think up a condition to prevent this in urban situations. Either on city limit information, or easily only after the absence of instructions for the past 1 or 2 km. You have to consider that often we are talking about crossings where you need to give way. Maybe you need the experience of such a situation to be able to value the idea

[Corjan Meijerink]

Not sure how I feel about this too.
Just like the request where people want the app to warn about sharp corners this falls sort of in that category.

When a dangerous crossing is coming up, there will be road signs / markings on the road to warn you about that
Just like a sudden sharp turn will be announced on the road itself.

Now that's my opinion as user of the app and enthusiastic rider

As developer - it would be a pain to develop given all the conditions when those announcements would be annoying and unnecessary. Also the information is now simply lacking from the active navigation guidance.

[Nick Carthew]

Would it be possible to connect the app to my cruise control?

[Con Hennekens]

@Corjan-Meijerink said in Announcements for going straight at a crossing:

Just like the request where people want the app to warn about sharp corners this falls sort of in that category.

I don't agree that this request falls into the same category (at all!). Navigation is there for giving directions. Why not give directions for going straight? Of course it would be nice if a warning could be given only when crossing a priority road, but I am not sure if there are parameters for that in the map data.

But as said earlier, this is mainly helpful on mountainesque forest roads. Dutch flatlanders will probably not value the idea...

[Con Hennekens]

@Peter-Schiefer said in Announcements for going straight at a crossing:

The instruction from the teacher was clear. „As long I say nothing we drive straight on“

I am not trying to teaching you how to drive, but trying to warn you for hidden accidents.

And me I have always „one“ eye on the map the check the route and my position.

Me too... If the HERE map actually had any detail, I would probably not have suggested this. So, you are wright...
@Corjan-Meijerink, please get HERE to release proper maps

[Nick Carthew]

@Nick-Carthew said in Announcements for going straight at a crossing:

Would it be possible to connect the app to my cruise control?

Have you lost your sense of humour with my remark @Con-Hennekens? -1

[Con Hennekens]

@Nick-Carthew, It's pulling a serious request into ridiculousness, so yes. There have been more than one occasions on which I found myself surprised by a crossing that was nearly invisible in reality as well on the map. So it is not just one more stupid idea. No hard feelings though

[GT JWR]

@Corjan-Meijerink the app would be endlessly talking if this was to be done....creating a more unsafe condition, IMO, as it would soon become an annoyance and many riders would tone it out.

[Bouke Ent]

I like it when the navigation lady does not say to much. I normaly try to drive on visual look at the screen where I can see the corners. To many warnings is not my thing. But Con is right about danger that is not always shown on the map or on the road but I think this kind of danger info does not be part of the Here road information that you can select.

[King 06]

This post is deleted!

[Rob Veerman]

It’s a bit like when creating a route, not too many shaping points. I am very happy with the way the anouncements are done in the current situation. Too much talking is irritating is my personal opinion.

[RetiredWingMan]

Huge reaction to what seemed like a simple request. My TomTom used to tell me to go straight when traveling on a multilane highway (not so much on other roads) and I found it very annoying to say the least. I think we have far too much automation in today's vehicles. It's no wonder people don't know how to drive unless the vehicle tells them what to do. I guess self driving vehicles will be the ultimate automation.

[Jörgen]

I like the idea too, but I think it should only give attention if the crossing has a STOP sign on my road. But is this possibel?

[King 06]

MHO
I read this and fear that it unfortunately applies to many drivers these days.

I have always „one“ eye on the map

Perhaps a good idea for everyone to have both eyes on the road. So that the next thing doesn't have to happen!

surprised by a crossing that was nearly invisible in reality

Fortunately, I also see these wise words.

When a dangerous crossing is coming up, there will be road signs / markings on the road to warn you about that
Just like a sudden sharp turn will be announced on the road itself.

You can read a road. But then you have to see it.

[Mzokk]

I don't think what is being requested is included in the Here maps attributes. It is on OSM maps as are speed bumps! Don't particularly needed as has been said keep eyes on the road

[Stephen Rowland]

My opinion is that a Sat Nav is there to guide you along a route so that you don't go wrong or get lost. It is not to take the place of diligently looking at road signs in order to keep yourself safe. No instruction means "stay on this road". If we start asking for straight on at junction, sharp bend, and hump back bridge warnings we will become lazy and forget to read the road. The we will be blaming the Dev's for accidents and going nuts with the amount of talking in our heads.

[Corjan Meijerink]

I believe enough has been said.
This request won’t be implemented

Thanks for all the insights!