Route could not be calculated
-
I am not offline. I tried on iPhone (no maps loaded) and on the Android phone there are downloaded maps. I try with and without avoid highway.
I only could think that I am may be to far away from Ireland. But I also deactivated „ use current position „.@Jörgen Distance has nothing to do with it. Here is a route that is in Australia, it opens ok on my iPhone.
-
wrote on 14 Apr 2025, 16:38 last edited by Thomas Neumeyer
Hello, I had yesterday the same message. I am on Android with Tab Active 3. Finally it was working but those kind of messages are a bit annoying. Actually I purchased the Gold version because of the good reviews but lately I am using more and more Osmand. Hope the next update has also a improved none routing map as I am not always on a track or route. However the route planner is very good.
-
@Jörgen hi Jorgen
When I use my IOS device I get the same error message as you.
However when I open the route on my Android Device the route opens and shows the route to the starting point@Marinus-van-Deudekom Good to know it is not only me.
I try to make more tests. I want to know the reason for this. -
@Marinus-van-Deudekom Good to know it is not only me.
I try to make more tests. I want to know the reason for this. -
@Rob-Verhoeff Strange, what could be the reason?
I tried to move the waypoint, no change. -
wrote on 15 Apr 2025, 18:16 last edited by
hi @Jörgen
I am currently in the UK in the peak district national park and have just opened a number of routes on my iphone that are also in Eire, (for a trip later in the year) and all opened and worked as expected, albiet navigating from my house
I tried it offline and online both with the same resultnot much help, sorry, just thought i would pass on my findings
-
I am not sure if this relevant, but I remember there was something in the past.
I am at my home WIFI and have may be (no) or bad GPS satellite signal -
wrote 23 days ago last edited by
I have the same problem. I create a route on the web MRA. When I open it on MRA Nav (ofline mode, maps downloaded), I have a message "can not calculate".
After a few seconds, it opens a route, but I see a route recalculated (I have a blue line as usual and at some parts I have a white line - like the original route when the app has recalculated)
Maybe I don't use good parameters on the web (I use Michelin map and here-Garmin calculating) -
wrote 23 days ago last edited by
Good morning. I tried the app now for about 2000 km in Austria and Italy. I must say that I expected more. Unstable with freezing of the app. Planned routes quite ok. Navigation from A to B not convenient with strange guiding. Route not able to be calculated. Free riding without routing not good. Support for Silverfox controller also not intuitive. Pushing zoom goes to the menue which is bad while driving. I will park the app until a better version is available. And yes I am on the latest version.
-
I have the same problem. I create a route on the web MRA. When I open it on MRA Nav (ofline mode, maps downloaded), I have a message "can not calculate".
After a few seconds, it opens a route, but I see a route recalculated (I have a blue line as usual and at some parts I have a white line - like the original route when the app has recalculated)
Maybe I don't use good parameters on the web (I use Michelin map and here-Garmin calculating)@Joce-Doubs, is this by any chance a route created by the roundtrip generator? Does this occur also for normal routes, where you placed waypoints yourself?
@Thomas-Neumeyer said in Route could not be calculated:
Pushing zoom goes to the menue which is bad while driving.
I suppose you are using a AA/CP device instead of the native app? The UI of an AA/CP app is very restricted due to limitations imposed by Google/Apple. A scenic route app like MRA has more functions to be operated than let's say Google Maps. That is why it is very hard to get the UI intuitive on such a device. The best navigating experience you will get when using the native app. It is not really MRA that can be blamed for this.
-
@Joce-Doubs, is this by any chance a route created by the roundtrip generator? Does this occur also for normal routes, where you placed waypoints yourself?
@Thomas-Neumeyer said in Route could not be calculated:
Pushing zoom goes to the menue which is bad while driving.
I suppose you are using a AA/CP device instead of the native app? The UI of an AA/CP app is very restricted due to limitations imposed by Google/Apple. A scenic route app like MRA has more functions to be operated than let's say Google Maps. That is why it is very hard to get the UI intuitive on such a device. The best navigating experience you will get when using the native app. It is not really MRA that can be blamed for this.
wrote 22 days ago last edited by@Con-Hennekens said in Route could not be calculated:
@Joce-Doubs, is this by any chance a route created by the roundtrip generator? Does this occur also for normal routes, where you placed waypoints yourself?
No, it's a route creatad by adding start , end, shaping points by myself
-
@Joce-Doubs, is this by any chance a route created by the roundtrip generator? Does this occur also for normal routes, where you placed waypoints yourself?
@Thomas-Neumeyer said in Route could not be calculated:
Pushing zoom goes to the menue which is bad while driving.
I suppose you are using a AA/CP device instead of the native app? The UI of an AA/CP app is very restricted due to limitations imposed by Google/Apple. A scenic route app like MRA has more functions to be operated than let's say Google Maps. That is why it is very hard to get the UI intuitive on such a device. The best navigating experience you will get when using the native app. It is not really MRA that can be blamed for this.
wrote 22 days ago last edited by@Con-Hennekens I have been using my Samsung tablet. I assume it is native together with the app. I am not using AA or CP at all. Today I gave it another trial. Route planned with planning tool from the app. Not the web version. Connected via hotspot. Route started. Lost connection and app went bananas. I have all required maps downloaded but routing was impossible. I thought the app is switching automatically to off line routing? Stopping the app and restart helped. Still not happy. Web based route planning works like a charm but. This I can state. But navigation next not really good.
-
@Con-Hennekens I have been using my Samsung tablet. I assume it is native together with the app. I am not using AA or CP at all. Today I gave it another trial. Route planned with planning tool from the app. Not the web version. Connected via hotspot. Route started. Lost connection and app went bananas. I have all required maps downloaded but routing was impossible. I thought the app is switching automatically to off line routing? Stopping the app and restart helped. Still not happy. Web based route planning works like a charm but. This I can state. But navigation next not really good.
@Thomas-Neumeyer Did you save your route after creating it in the app route planner? I might be wrong, but I believe that to use a route offline that was created in the app route planner you would need to save it before using it.
-
@Thomas-Neumeyer Did you save your route after creating it in the app route planner? I might be wrong, but I believe that to use a route offline that was created in the app route planner you would need to save it before using it.
wrote 22 days ago last edited by@Nick-Carthew Yes I saved it.
-
@Con-Hennekens I have been using my Samsung tablet. I assume it is native together with the app. I am not using AA or CP at all. Today I gave it another trial. Route planned with planning tool from the app. Not the web version. Connected via hotspot. Route started. Lost connection and app went bananas. I have all required maps downloaded but routing was impossible. I thought the app is switching automatically to off line routing? Stopping the app and restart helped. Still not happy. Web based route planning works like a charm but. This I can state. But navigation next not really good.
@Thomas-Neumeyer said in Route could not be calculated:
app went bananas
That is a nice description, but not really informative. Can you elaborate?
There is an option in de settings that says "Navigate routes as tracks" (or similar in English). Is that enabled? Disable it and try again. Tracks can only be calculated online, but the app should make an approximation and throw a message about that.
@Thomas-Neumeyer said in Route could not be calculated:
I thought the app is switching automatically to off line routing?
No, it will always throw a message to ask if you want to go online or offline.
-
@Thomas-Neumeyer said in Route could not be calculated:
app went bananas
That is a nice description, but not really informative. Can you elaborate?
There is an option in de settings that says "Navigate routes as tracks" (or similar in English). Is that enabled? Disable it and try again. Tracks can only be calculated online, but the app should make an approximation and throw a message about that.
@Thomas-Neumeyer said in Route could not be calculated:
I thought the app is switching automatically to off line routing?
No, it will always throw a message to ask if you want to go online or offline.
wrote 20 days ago last edited by@Con-Hennekens Bananas means that the app told, route can not be calculated, tried to recalculate, route can not be calculated, tried to recalculate, route can not be calculated and so on. I stopped it then. To be honest in this situation in an area without knowing where you are this is quite let’s say bad. Even the OEM app and arrow navigation is able to recalculate. As far I remember in the live blog from the developer it was stated that it switches to offline mode automatically. But I have to admit that I am not 100 % sure. Today I navigated with a A to B navigation. Was working fine except that there were the „original“ bright blue lines to see. But not following the street just straight lines. But I am sure this can be disabled somewhere in the settings.
undefined
