Segments, Silver and Season Challenge live!
-
At first, I was enthousiastic about the spirit of this feature, as it's quite useful. But my second tought was : "pourvu que ça marche" (let's face it, MRA does have bad habit of very regularly breaking old things). Well ... I think I can attribute my current error to this new feature, as it only occurs in OSM...
I have this recently created route of about 430 km (probably just a little before the introduction of this feature)... It's a ride of a little over 6 hours, from W-Belgium to roughly Koblenz, in a mixture of highways and secundary roads. See screenshot 1 showing a part of it.
If I open it in its original form, based on OpenStreetMap, I no longer get the routepoints informations in the left part of the screen (it's all white now). See screenshot 2. Also notice that even if the routepoints are still present, as from point 18, the line connecting these points is no longer there. Also the total distance and the foreseen duration to ride that route are missing at the top left part of the window.
Then, with a "hack" (or call it a "trick" - but please don't call it a solution !!!), creating an extra route point right after leaving the highway (see screenshot 3), I obtain the route points infos again - for the biggest number of them, as some are still missing. Only, the total distance is off by 150 km, and the expected duration to ride the route is off by 2 hours and a half.
Opening it in as well HERE as well as in TomTom shows correct times.
Back to the drawing board ? I can understand things get broken accidently, but it happens all too often in MRA's case. I would appreciate it not to be continuously considered as "beta-testing customer". Speaking for myself, I can assure you I appreciate a product that's not broken that often. Maybe MRA could better test things proactively, rather than fix things things that shouldn't have been broken in the first place ? I bet MRA is doing "agile" programming, doing "sprints". Why not, buzzwords are sexy. If only they resulted in better and more stable software.
Screenshot 1
Screenshot 2
Screenshot 3
-
I am quite enthusiastic about the new Segments feature.
This is really helpful planning real routes with nice parts!I also understand that some/most of the navigation systems do not support this feature and we have to expand routes to overcome the missing feature in the navigation system.
BUT: I woud have expected that the MRA Navigator is able to use this feature.
Unfortunately it is not able to handle this new feature.Will MRA Navigator in the future also support Segments without expanding routes?
Many thanks.
Tom -
I am quite enthusiastic about the new Segments feature.
This is really helpful planning real routes with nice parts!I also understand that some/most of the navigation systems do not support this feature and we have to expand routes to overcome the missing feature in the navigation system.
BUT: I woud have expected that the MRA Navigator is able to use this feature.
Unfortunately it is not able to handle this new feature.Will MRA Navigator in the future also support Segments without expanding routes?
Many thanks.
Tom@tom-johann
Hello Tom,MRA Navigation uses the Here map, so as long as the Here map is used for Navigation, the segments will not be copied.
Solution: When your route is completely ready, add x number of waypoints and convert the route by using the Here map as a planning map, the route will then be mostly the same. Always check the route points. -
We have made another major adjustment to our routeplanner. With segments you can split the route into different parts, and give each part a different setting. For example, you drive the first part of the route on the highway, and you drive the second part through beautiful nature and avoid highways!Do you think a Gold subscription is still too exciting? We have a new subscription that allows you to make cheaper routes, but still work like a pro. This is the MRA Routeplanner Silver subscription. We've made a couple of landing pages where you can compare the features.
In addition, a community challenge is now live! The Season Challenge was designed to get you back in the saddle!
@timo-martosatiman-mra
https://www.myrouteapp.com/en/social/route/6105923?mode=share
The the public route above does not seem to do what I was expecting between segment points 2-3.
I guess I may be doing something wrong?
Point 1 to 2 is correct and is the fastest way to get to Point 2.
However as Point 3 is set to the highest Curvy Roads I find it strange that it chooses to Route me on the A21 for 90% of Segment 2-3.
The A21 is Major Dual Carriageway that in places is 3 lanes wide.
Using the Scenic Route Generator creates exactly the same route for Points 2-3?
The route below generated by the Tom Tom Curvy Routes in MRA is an example of what I would have expected between points 2-3?
You don’t stop riding when you get old, you get old when you stop riding.
-
@timo-martosatiman-mra
https://www.myrouteapp.com/en/social/route/6105923?mode=share
The the public route above does not seem to do what I was expecting between segment points 2-3.
I guess I may be doing something wrong?
Point 1 to 2 is correct and is the fastest way to get to Point 2.
However as Point 3 is set to the highest Curvy Roads I find it strange that it chooses to Route me on the A21 for 90% of Segment 2-3.
The A21 is Major Dual Carriageway that in places is 3 lanes wide.
Using the Scenic Route Generator creates exactly the same route for Points 2-3?The route below generated by the Tom Tom Curvy Routes in MRA is an example of what I would have expected between points 2-3?
Hello @Steve-Lynch
TomTom uses a different map and algorithm to determine the route, so comparing these 2 is like comparing apples and oranges
Garmin Zumo XT2/XT/BMW Connected Ride Navigator/MyRouteapp (The App)
Een dag niet gelachen is een dag niet geleefd / Een route is net zo goed als deze uitgezet is. -
Hello @Steve-Lynch
TomTom uses a different map and algorithm to determine the route, so comparing these 2 is like comparing apples and oranges
@hans-van-de-ven-mra-master
Yes that is a fair enough comment, but forgetting the Tom Tom example and looking at the OSM example in isolation, having set it to to the highest Curvy Roads option it seems strange that it routes me on a major dual carriageway.
I was hoping I was doing something wrong?You don’t stop riding when you get old, you get old when you stop riding.
-
@hans-van-de-ven-mra-master
Yes that is a fair enough comment, but forgetting the Tom Tom example and looking at the OSM example in isolation, having set it to to the highest Curvy Roads option it seems strange that it routes me on a major dual carriageway.
I was hoping I was doing something wrong?@steve-lynch I guess it's safe to conclude that we now know as well why the OSM is available free of charge and TomTom is not. That obviously comes at a price haha. The OSM algorithm kist seems to "suck" compared to Tom.
Manks bu'j te bange.
-
@steve-lynch I guess it's safe to conclude that we now know as well why the OSM is available free of charge and TomTom is not. That obviously comes at a price haha. The OSM algorithm kist seems to "suck" compared to Tom.
@stefanhummelink
I do have a Tom Tom 550 but my preferred device is now a Garmin Zumo XT due to my ageing eyes.
Due to the awesome functionality of the MRA Route Planner I can use the Tom Tom algorithm and then switch to the Here Map and convert it ready for import via the Connector to my XT.
Happy days
-
@steve-lynch I guess it's safe to conclude that we now know as well why the OSM is available free of charge and TomTom is not. That obviously comes at a price haha. The OSM algorithm kist seems to "suck" compared to Tom.
@stefanhummelink said in Segments, Silver and Season Challenge live!:
@steve-lynch I guess it's safe to conclude that we now know as well why the OSM is available free of charge and TomTom is not. That obviously comes at a price haha. The OSM algorithm kist seems to "suck" compared to Tom.
Are you sure it is OSM that provides the algorithm, Stefan ? I am not at all, as OSM is map material gathered from inputs from people from all around the world. Open, yes indeed. Free, yes indeed. But I doubt there is an algorithm coming with it ?
I've seen no difference between the "curvy roads" setting and the "very curvy road" setting in MRA, up to now.
-
@stefanhummelink said in Segments, Silver and Season Challenge live!:
@steve-lynch I guess it's safe to conclude that we now know as well why the OSM is available free of charge and TomTom is not. That obviously comes at a price haha. The OSM algorithm kist seems to "suck" compared to Tom.
Are you sure it is OSM that provides the algorithm, Stefan ? I am not at all, as OSM is map material gathered from inputs from people from all around the world. Open, yes indeed. Free, yes indeed. But I doubt there is an algorithm coming with it ?
I've seen no difference between the "curvy roads" setting and the "very curvy road" setting in MRA, up to now.
@sudolea I'm not sure, but simply assuming. I would however not expect the algorithm to be coming from MRA and only using the map data? In that case, the fault is at MRA hahah.
-
undefined MyRoute-app community unpinned this topic on
