Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?
-
@CD130 said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
The tunnel is closed.
You can see it with the traffic overlay map and on TomTom route planner.
wrote on 30 Sept 2024, 14:46 last edited by Rob Verhoeff@Nick-Carthew said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
The tunnel is closed.
So is the Mont Blanctunnel! If you disable seasonal closures, you can go through that tunnel. That should also work in this tunnel, right?
-
@Nick-Carthew said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
The tunnel is closed.
So is the Mont Blanctunnel! If you disable seasonal closures, you can go through that tunnel. That should also work in this tunnel, right?
@Rob-Verhoeff said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
@Nick-Carthew said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
The tunnel is closed.
So is the Mont Blanctunnel! If you disable seasonal closures, you can go through that tunnel. That should also work in this tunnel, right?
Sometimes turning on seasonal closures will also work with roads closed for construction, but not always. I think it depends on how the closure is classified.
-
@Rob-Verhoeff said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
@Nick-Carthew said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
The tunnel is closed.
So is the Mont Blanctunnel! If you disable seasonal closures, you can go through that tunnel. That should also work in this tunnel, right?
Sometimes turning on seasonal closures will also work with roads closed for construction, but not always. I think it depends on how the closure is classified.
wrote on 30 Sept 2024, 14:57 last edited by@Nick-Carthew Do you have another example of this? I've never experienced that before...
-
@Nick-Carthew Do you have another example of this? I've never experienced that before...
@CD130 said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
@Nick-Carthew Do you have another example of this? I've never experienced that before...
What would you like an example of?
-
wrote on 30 Sept 2024, 15:00 last edited by
Hi @CD130
As Nick already mentioned, this road is closed at the beginning and the end of the tunnelroad.
You can find actual information at : https://www.viamichelin.com/maps/traffic/italy/piedmont/cuneo/panice_soprana-12015.I hope this information helps you further.
-
@Rob-Verhoeff said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
@Nick-Carthew said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
The tunnel is closed.
So is the Mont Blanctunnel! If you disable seasonal closures, you can go through that tunnel. That should also work in this tunnel, right?
Sometimes turning on seasonal closures will also work with roads closed for construction, but not always. I think it depends on how the closure is classified.
wrote on 30 Sept 2024, 15:01 last edited by@Nick-Carthew said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
I think it depends on how the closure is classified.
Tried it out with some road closures in the Netherlands. I can bypass all of them by disabling seasonal closures.
-
@Nick-Carthew said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
I think it depends on how the closure is classified.
Tried it out with some road closures in the Netherlands. I can bypass all of them by disabling seasonal closures.
wrote on 30 Sept 2024, 15:33 last edited by@Rob-Verhoeff
I understand your point well, but even with disabling seasonal closures and adding extra waypoints, it's still not possible to navigate through the tunnel. But why would you want to do this? If you manipulate the route that much and then decide to drive it, you'll face the problem that you simply can't pass through.
The only way to force through the tunnel is by skipping waypoints.
But even that doesn't solve the problem that the tunnel is closed.
-
@Rob-Verhoeff
I understand your point well, but even with disabling seasonal closures and adding extra waypoints, it's still not possible to navigate through the tunnel. But why would you want to do this? If you manipulate the route that much and then decide to drive it, you'll face the problem that you simply can't pass through.The only way to force through the tunnel is by skipping waypoints.
But even that doesn't solve the problem that the tunnel is closed.wrote on 30 Sept 2024, 15:49 last edited by@Albert-van-den-Elsen said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
But why would you want to do this?
I would like to have it calculated through the tunnel so that I can properly prepare my trip, which I want to drive later when the tunnel is open again, in terms of travel time and distance.
-
@CD130 said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
@Nick-Carthew Do you have another example of this? I've never experienced that before...
What would you like an example of?
wrote on 30 Sept 2024, 15:50 last edited by@Nick-Carthew said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
@CD130 said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
@Nick-Carthew Do you have another example of this? I've never experienced that before...
What would you like an example of?
An example of a location that is closed and where it really is not possible to navigate over it.
-
@Nick-Carthew said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
@CD130 said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
@Nick-Carthew Do you have another example of this? I've never experienced that before...
What would you like an example of?
An example of a location that is closed and where it really is not possible to navigate over it.
@CD130 No, I don't have any other examples to show you, but over the years of using MRA I have seen examples where the Seasonal closure tool does not work.
-
wrote on 30 Sept 2024, 17:44 last edited by
This is what https://mapcreator.here.com/ is showing:
-
wrote on 30 Sept 2024, 18:05 last edited by
Message to the MRA team (@Corjan-Meijerink): Is there anything you can do about this behind the scenes at MRA? Please make the routeplanner so that we can plan routes ourselves. Also on roads that are currently closed, but will be open again in a few months.
-
Message to the MRA team (@Corjan-Meijerink): Is there anything you can do about this behind the scenes at MRA? Please make the routeplanner so that we can plan routes ourselves. Also on roads that are currently closed, but will be open again in a few months.
wrote on 30 Sept 2024, 23:31 last edited by@CD130 use the skip function to cause a connection between waypoints at both ends of the tunnel.
-
Ik krijg het met geen mogelijkheid voor elkaar om met de MRA Routeplanner door deze tunnel te navigeren. Lukt het iemand anders wel?
--
I can't seem to navigate through this tunnel with the MRA Routeplanner. Does anyone else have any success?
--
Route: https://www.myrouteapp.com/nl/social/route/10066243?mode=sharewrote on 1 Oct 2024, 18:05 last edited by Con Hennekens 10 Jan 2024, 18:05@CD130, Personally I like the reroute A LOT better...
-
@CD130, Personally I like the reroute A LOT better...
wrote on 1 Oct 2024, 19:10 last edited by@Con-Hennekens Hahaha totally agree
-
Message to the MRA team (@Corjan-Meijerink): Is there anything you can do about this behind the scenes at MRA? Please make the routeplanner so that we can plan routes ourselves. Also on roads that are currently closed, but will be open again in a few months.
wrote on 2 Oct 2024, 10:09 last edited by@CD130 said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
Message to the MRA team (@Corjan-Meijerink): Is there anything you can do about this behind the scenes at MRA? Please make the routeplanner so that we can plan routes ourselves. Also on roads that are currently closed, but will be open again in a few months.
I do not see how... That is where the seasonal closures are for explicitly. In this case it looks to be a permanent closure in the base mapdata. I do not think there is a way around that (in the metaphorical sense
)On here: https://www.wegenwiki.nl/Tunnel_de_Tende
I read that the tunnel was badly damaged by floods in 2020. Reopening is scheduled for the end of this year. So the permanent closure is probably deliberate too... -
@CD130 said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
Message to the MRA team (@Corjan-Meijerink): Is there anything you can do about this behind the scenes at MRA? Please make the routeplanner so that we can plan routes ourselves. Also on roads that are currently closed, but will be open again in a few months.
I do not see how... That is where the seasonal closures are for explicitly. In this case it looks to be a permanent closure in the base mapdata. I do not think there is a way around that (in the metaphorical sense
)On here: https://www.wegenwiki.nl/Tunnel_de_Tende
I read that the tunnel was badly damaged by floods in 2020. Reopening is scheduled for the end of this year. So the permanent closure is probably deliberate too...wrote on 2 Oct 2024, 10:19 last edited by@Con-Hennekens said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
I do not see how...
It would be great if we could also use offline maps in the new web planner! After all, all closures are included in the online maps, right?
-
@Con-Hennekens said in Tun. du Col de Tende... Cause/bug at MRA or HERE?:
I do not see how...
It would be great if we could also use offline maps in the new web planner! After all, all closures are included in the online maps, right?
wrote on 2 Oct 2024, 10:29 last edited by@Rob-Verhoeff, I seriously predict you are in for a surprise!
But I guess that will not be anytime soon. I am not sure however how that would change a permanently closed road/tunnel? My guess is that, because of the more permanent character of this tunnel closure they closed it in the base mapdata, You would be downloading that closure also, just like with the online map. I don't see the difference. -
@Rob-Verhoeff, I seriously predict you are in for a surprise!
But I guess that will not be anytime soon. I am not sure however how that would change a permanently closed road/tunnel? My guess is that, because of the more permanent character of this tunnel closure they closed it in the base mapdata, You would be downloading that closure also, just like with the online map. I don't see the difference.wrote on 2 Oct 2024, 10:39 last edited by@Con-Hennekens If I'm not mistaken, the current offline maps you use on your phone don't include road closures either. It's entirely possible that I go a year without updating my offline maps. That would mean you're always stuck with built-in road closures. Right?
But, it's an idea that could make planning less dependent on these kinds of issues in the future. Maybe it's worth looking into...
-
@Con-Hennekens If I'm not mistaken, the current offline maps you use on your phone don't include road closures either. It's entirely possible that I go a year without updating my offline maps. That would mean you're always stuck with built-in road closures. Right?
But, it's an idea that could make planning less dependent on these kinds of issues in the future. Maybe it's worth looking into...
wrote on 2 Oct 2024, 11:21 last edited by@Rob-Verhoeff, The offline maps probably don't contain seasonal closures indeed. But the closure of the Tunnel du Col de Tende looks like a permanent one (until declared open by the local government). I think not being able to route through it is explicitly because it is not routeable in the base mapdata. It is not a seasonal closure. It also shows a different line pattern then the Mont Blanc tunnel for example. Sometimes you also see roads on maps that are still being built and therefore not open yet. My guess is that such things are in the base mapdata, and not in the seasonal closures.
