Feature suggestion - realtime collaborative editing
-
wrote on 18 Sept 2019, 10:14 last edited by
Practical example - myself and a friend want to edit a route together, in realtime. We are planning a route out together, using Discord for chat, and we're looking at a map and plotting a route together. At the moment, one person (the admin) has to take on the role of creating the route. The only way the other person can see progress is to exit and re-load the admin's shared route. Trying to convey route ideas is all verbal.
What would be so much easier and more powerful is if we could place markers, or a sort of laser-pointer, for each user that the route owner can then "adopt" into the route.... it would allow discussion then; users could place a marker for a desirable place to go or a waypoint they'd like to include in the route. The master owner (the admin) still have to final say on creating the route - he can adopt or ignore those markers into the route - but it allows people to work in realtime discussing and planning the route interactively. Much better than a cycle of emails of "I'd like to go here", followed by a revision to the route by the owner, who then asks the friends to review, who then feedback that he got a waypoint wrong it was supposed to be at the other end of road XYZ, so he reloads the route, fixed it, re-issues it for review, everyone re-loads it, yada yada yada
you get the idea I'm sure!Think Google Drive collaborative editing of a spreadsheet or document, but on routes instead
-
Practical example - myself and a friend want to edit a route together, in realtime. We are planning a route out together, using Discord for chat, and we're looking at a map and plotting a route together. At the moment, one person (the admin) has to take on the role of creating the route. The only way the other person can see progress is to exit and re-load the admin's shared route. Trying to convey route ideas is all verbal.
What would be so much easier and more powerful is if we could place markers, or a sort of laser-pointer, for each user that the route owner can then "adopt" into the route.... it would allow discussion then; users could place a marker for a desirable place to go or a waypoint they'd like to include in the route. The master owner (the admin) still have to final say on creating the route - he can adopt or ignore those markers into the route - but it allows people to work in realtime discussing and planning the route interactively. Much better than a cycle of emails of "I'd like to go here", followed by a revision to the route by the owner, who then asks the friends to review, who then feedback that he got a waypoint wrong it was supposed to be at the other end of road XYZ, so he reloads the route, fixed it, re-issues it for review, everyone re-loads it, yada yada yada
you get the idea I'm sure!Think Google Drive collaborative editing of a spreadsheet or document, but on routes instead
@Dan-Howell I'm lucky that my riding buddies leave the route planning entirely up to me. For longer tours I ask everyone (normally over a pint
or two) where they would like to visit and I try to build that into the tour. Sometimes it isn't always possible to accommodate everyone's wishes, but I am the Route Master and I rule by dictatorship rather than democracy 
-
We actually talked about this a lot back in the day (2014). Played around with several use cases of varying levels of difficulty. In the end it was added to a list of features that we'd like to work on but needs to be done properly and will require a high level of effort to be done the right way.
-
In the meantime @Dan-Howell could probably use a tool like TeamViewer, to share and collaborate the entire desktop for this purpose. I think however that it is extremely difficult to "keep out of eachothers way" (quite literally
) while editing a route simultaneously... -
In the meantime @Dan-Howell could probably use a tool like TeamViewer, to share and collaborate the entire desktop for this purpose. I think however that it is extremely difficult to "keep out of eachothers way" (quite literally
) while editing a route simultaneously...wrote on 19 Sept 2019, 08:51 last edited by@Con-Hennekens said in Feature suggestion - realtime collaborative editing:
In the meantime @Dan-Howell could probably use a tool like TeamViewer, to share and collaborate the entire desktop for this purpose. I think however that it is extremely difficult to "keep out of eachothers way" (quite literally
) while editing a route simultaneously...That's certainly a fall-back option I suppose, yes. Not as slick but it could work :). Even just allowing multiple people to edit a route (even if it's not simultaneously, one person locks and the others can only view) would be a step in the right direction....
-
undefined Philippe Parys referenced this topic on 6 Jan 2023, 11:02