Visualizing unpaved roads
-
@sudolea Thanks for the update. I have just started using the OSM editor to add some local information so I may need to reach out for some help!
Thanks!
Steve
@steve-jarrell Steve, I myself have also already edited some OSM map data; most of the times I don't feel very confident about my edits. However, there is an option to ask people who are more familiar with editing the map material to audit your changes before they get "live"...
-
@steve-jarrell Steve, I myself have also already edited some OSM map data; most of the times I don't feel very confident about my edits. However, there is an option to ask people who are more familiar with editing the map material to audit your changes before they get "live"...
@sudolea Thanks. Yes, I saw and checked that option. It's not real intuitive. It will tell you there's a potential problem, but it doesn't give you hardly any indication of what the problem is or how to resolve it. I guess I'll have to watch a few more of the videos and read more of the manual. I'll figure out the basics.... somehow..... someday.
Thanks!
Steve
-
Re: Unpaved roads vs color contrast and permanently closed roads motorcyclists
In my area I ride a combination of paved and unpaved roads when I'm on my smaller motorcycle (Husqvarna Svartpilen 401), however I like to avoid the unpaved sections if possible when I'm on my larger touring bike (Honda Goldwing). It's really nice to be able to quickly visualize that route and see if it has unpaved sections, and if so how many there are and how long they are.
The Kurvinger.de route planner solved this issue using OpenStreetMaps both on the map itself and in their elevation view. In the following screenshot the blue sections are paved and the brown are unpaved.
It would be GREAT if MRA could implement this feature in the future!
Steve
@Steve-Jarrell Steve, I am totally with you on that request! I is a big missing part in MRA.
Btw, I was just playing with Kurviger (never heard of it before your mentioning it). I don't get to see unpaved roads like you do... Is it only for subscribed members?
Thanks!Positive emotions are worth every penny ;)
-
@Steve-Jarrell Steve, I am totally with you on that request! I is a big missing part in MRA.
Btw, I was just playing with Kurviger (never heard of it before your mentioning it). I don't get to see unpaved roads like you do... Is it only for subscribed members?
Thanks!@Lenny-O That is a paid version (Tourer or Tourer+) feature.
Steve Jarrell
Western North Carolina USLifetime Routeplanner Gold & Navigation Next
2025 BMW R1300GS
2025 Can-Am Spyder
DMD T865-X 8" Tablet
Garmin XT3 -
@Lenny-O That is a paid version (Tourer or Tourer+) feature.
@Steve-Jarrell Thank you!
As of late, we still have no way to tell in MRA, right?Positive emotions are worth every penny ;)
-
@Steve-Jarrell Thank you!
As of late, we still have no way to tell in MRA, right?@Lenny-O Not that I know of.
MRA does have an "avoid unpaved roads" option but that isn't the same thing as visualizing the unpaved section. For example, the unpaved section may only be 100 meters long and would be perfectly rideable but MRA will completely avoid it, many times taking you on a much longer and much less desirable route.
Steve Jarrell
Western North Carolina USLifetime Routeplanner Gold & Navigation Next
2025 BMW R1300GS
2025 Can-Am Spyder
DMD T865-X 8" Tablet
Garmin XT3 -
@Lenny-O Not that I know of.
MRA does have an "avoid unpaved roads" option but that isn't the same thing as visualizing the unpaved section. For example, the unpaved section may only be 100 meters long and would be perfectly rideable but MRA will completely avoid it, many times taking you on a much longer and much less desirable route.
@Steve-Jarrell MRA sends you on unpaved road even if Avoid unpaved roads is selected... That's my biggest problem with that.
Positive emotions are worth every penny ;)
-
@Steve-Jarrell MRA sends you on unpaved road even if Avoid unpaved roads is selected... That's my biggest problem with that.
@Lenny-O Which maps are you using? If you're not already using the OSM maps see if using them solves that issue. I have had some issues with the HERE/Garmin maps so I always double check a route using the OSM maps.
Steve Jarrell
Western North Carolina USLifetime Routeplanner Gold & Navigation Next
2025 BMW R1300GS
2025 Can-Am Spyder
DMD T865-X 8" Tablet
Garmin XT3 -
@Lenny-O Which maps are you using? If you're not already using the OSM maps see if using them solves that issue. I have had some issues with the HERE/Garmin maps so I always double check a route using the OSM maps.
@Steve-Jarrell Since I use Garmin for Nav, I am using the HERE map as MRA recommends... Do you use OSM instead? Do you have any issues with Garmin navigation (if you use Garmin) or you just use OSM for verification?
Thanks for help! -
@hans-van-de-ven-mra-master Unfortunately that's not the case with many unpaved roads and the Here maps (at least in my area). Even if they were shown in a slightly different color, once I've made my route the route line covers up the different color that indicates that it is a dirt road, so if I go back to the route in the future I have no idea it goes over an unpaved road just by looking at it.
Take a look at the screenshots below that illustrate what I'm talking about. Technologically it is possible to show unpaved roads very clearly as routes are being created and afterwards using OpenStreetMaps. Whether that's a feature that's worth investing development time in or not is another question entirely.
Thanks for your help! I sincerely appreciate it!
Steve
Hi Steve, I have already submitted a proposal to the programmers a while ago to include this in the planner if possible. Something like in the picture. (Red is unpaved)
-
The way OSM displays the layers depends on the stylesheet used when rendering the tiles.
Different tiles servers that use OSM render there tiles with a different stylesheet.Depending on the stylesheet the tiles are rendered different.
for example the OSM standard map and the opencyclemap use the same data but look different. -
The way OSM displays the layers depends on the stylesheet used when rendering the tiles.
Different tiles servers that use OSM render there tiles with a different stylesheet.Depending on the stylesheet the tiles are rendered different.
for example the OSM standard map and the opencyclemap use the same data but look different. -
Hi Steve, I have already submitted a proposal to the programmers a while ago to include this in the planner if possible. Something like in the picture. (Red is unpaved)
@Hans-van-de-Ven-MR-MRA That would be a very, very useful feature! Thanks very much for the update and trying to get this feature implemented!!
-
Kurviger uses the tileserver from Mapilion with his own stylesheet.
If you want to play with styles have a look here:
https://maplibre.org/maputnik/?layer=950344674~17#16.72/51.054925/16.312058@BertM Thanks. That's very interesting!
Hopefully the MRA guys can figure out how to make it happen! They've already implemented many, many very sophisticated and useful features that I would have never dreamed of so I'm confident they can do this as well if it makes its way to the priority list at some point.
-
I agree completely. It's one of the very, very few features that Kurviger has that's demonstrably better than MRA.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
-
01028
-
022442
-
05113
-
013362
-
0451
-
04125
-
07124
-
0253
